This disabled Islington woman is a prisoner in her inaccessible flat. How many others are stuck like this?

Last week, I wrote about Islington woman Ann Sparling, 47.

Ann lives in a 4th floor Islington council flat with her daughter, who is 15 and her son, who is 17. Ann has serious osteoarthritis in her knees. She’s had surgery several times. She walks with crutches. She is in constant pain.

There is no lift in Ann’s building. She must use the stairs to leave the building.

Ann can’t walk up and down these stairs. She recently stayed in the flat for 41 days straight, because her knees were bad and she found the stairs impossible. Occasionally, on a better day, Ann’s children help her down the stairs so that she can go outside. They hold onto her as she walks the steps. Ann’s children are her carers. They help her in and out of the bath and do the shopping, and so on.

Ann lives in fear of fire, or an emergency, because she can’t leave the flat by herself. She’s trapped.

I went to see Ann on Sunday. These are the stairs that she is expected to navigate:

Ann first asked Islington council to move her to an accessible flat three years ago. Nothing happened.

Last week, when people started tweeting this post, things started to happen – after a fashion. A council officer called Ann to collect her details and note down her difficulties. The council sent Ann a form for an occupational therapy assessment.

That was a start.

Ann’s problems will only be solved, of course, when she is moved to an accessible flat.

The council was reluctant to give me a timeframe for that, or to get down to specifics.

Any specifics, that is.

I asked the council several times how many sick, disabled and elderly people are stuck in the isolated and potentially lethal situation described here. I’ve asked the council about this several times.

This is crucial. Since my last post, people in different parts of the country have been in touch to say that disabled family members have indeed been stuck in inaccessible flats.

Ann says that the officer who spoke to her last week wondered the same thing: “[the officer said] it makes you wonder how many people are in the same way.”

Islington council refuses to answer questions about the number of people in Ann’s situation. Nor will the council say what plans it has in place to make sure that people who live in inaccessible housing can get out in an emergency. Does the council even know who and where everybody in this sort of situation is?

I think that the council does not.

The council sent me the usual We’re In A Housing Crisis statement – as opposed to answers:

“London is in the grip of a major housing crisis…There is a desperate need for secure, genuinely affordable housing to help people in very difficult circumstances…The council is doing everything it can to help tackle this problem and help residents into safe, genuinely affordable homes…” etc, etc.

That, as I say, is a statement, not an answer. I know London is in the grip of a housing crisis. Problem is that disabled people and people in poverty are expected to take the deadly fallout.

Osteoarthritis, can’t walk up 4 flights to the flat – and no lift. How many disabled people are trapped like this?

Update Monday 6 August:

Am a little tired of being ignored by councils, so I tweeted the Islington council leader and the member for housing, and asked them to look into Ann’s situation:

The member for housing said he would:

I understand that the council has called Ann today. That’s a start, at least. We push on.

I am still waiting for responses to other questions I asked – for example, I want to know how many disabled people are stuck in flats they can’t easily leave and are waiting for accessible housing.

More updates soon.


Original post (Friday 3 August):

Islington woman Ann Sparling, 47, is trapped in her fourth floor council flat.

Ann has serious osteoarthritis in both of her knees. There is no lift in her building. She must walk down and up four flights of stairs if she wants to leave her flat.

Ann says that she finds climbing the steps impossible. So, she is trapped.

She lives in fear of fire. Ann says the fire alarm in the building went off recently, and “I was terrified about not being able to get out.”

Ann’s been asking the council to move her to an accessible flat for three years. Nothing’s happened. I asked the council for comment on this situation on Monday. Nothing’s happened there either.

The council hasn’t even sent me a general statement.

I want to know how many sick or disabled people are trapped in this potentially lethal way and what is going to be done.

Ann relies on her two adolescent children to bring the shopping and run other chores. I guess it will be up to them to get Ann out if there’s a fire.

Ann’s own doctors insist that she be moved. They say she can’t cope with the stairs and must be rehoused. Her surgeons even delayed knee surgery last year, because Ann didn’t want to return to her fourth floor flat to recuperate.

Here’s an excerpt from a letter written by Ann’s doctor this year:Letter advising of required flat move

Ann reports that the council has told her there are no suitable properties available.

Ann also says communicating with the council is a pain. Emails go unrecorded and calls to housing options go unanswered.

I know that feeling. I asked the council about Ann’s situation and council communications on Monday. I’d heard nothing by Wednesday, so called the press office again. An officer said the council had to check that Ann would permit the council to discuss her details with me. The officer said a general statement might be forthcoming. It hasn’t been. I’ve heard nothing.

I am sick of this.

I say it again.

How many disabled people around the country are stuck and isolated in unpleasant and downright dangerous situations like this?

Have we learned nothing from fire disasters such as Grenfell – you know, making sure that people are safely housed and can get out?

Why do councils refuse to respond?

Somebody at Islington council needs to get in touch with me.