Barnet council’s mass outsourcing plan and the perils of privatisation

Big, bad privatisation plans and failed private-public projects have caused near-meltdowns at Cornwall  and Somerset councils in recent times – but that hasn’t stopped Tory Barnet council from storming towards oblivion with a plan called One Barnet – a deeply unpopular proposal to outsource swathes of council services which has brought the council to its knees before it has even begun. With just a few weeks left before the first major One Barnet contract is decided, this post looks at the controversy and a bit of Barnet council’s outsourcing history.

Photo: a protestor at a march and rally for Fremantle careworkers, 2007 (By @skinnyvoice)

I first became aware of the problems faced by people who were on the rough end of Barnet council’s privatisation deals in 2007.

That was when I started to spend Wednesday evenings at union shop meetings held by Barnet careworkers whose lives had been wrecked by outsourcing.

The careworkers were a group of low-paid staff (mostly women) who were in the middle of a bitter industrial dispute with the Fremantle Trust (a partner of Catalyst Housing) – the so-called not-for-profit organisation to which Barnet council had outsourced care for elderly people.

Earlier that year, the Trust had slaughtered the careworkers’ salaries and terms of employment. Their wages and working conditions had (supposedly) been protected when the council privatised care and TUPE-transferred staff to their new, outsourced employer – “they said it was all going to be super duper and we were going to be fine,” careworker Carmel Reynolds told me in 2007 – but in December 2006, the Trust made its move.

Staff were presented with a harsh new employment contract and told that anyone who refused to sign it by April 2007 would be sacked. With the new contract, the Trust cut careworkers’ annual leave allowances and reduced their sick leave to a statutory minimum. Worst of all was the abolishing of the weekend enhancement payments that many careworkers relied on to make up a reasonable wage. Barnet Unison estimated that after those cuts, some careworkers lost 30% of their pay.

When they complained, staff were told by management that they could make up their lost pay by working extra shifts. ‘I said [to management] – how do you expect us to be able to cope [with these cuts]? What [management] said is that you have to do extra hours to make up your pay. But what about the quality of our daily life?” said careworker Lango Gamanga in 2007.

The truly appalling part of all this, though – the part should not be forgotten in light of Barnet’s current outsourcing quest – was the discovery, late in 2007, that the cuts to the careworkers’ salaries and conditions had very likely been for nothing.

In a 6 December 2007 cabinet resources committee report, the council admitted that the “high profile” change (by which, presumably, it meant the much-publicised industrial dispute over the new contract) had not helped Catalyst blunt financial losses and that those losses presented “an ongoing and increasing budget risk to the council.” Catalyst lodged a claim for further funds from the council – and was ultimately awarded £8m in arbitration. So. The moral of this tale is that outsourcing often goes arse-over for everyone involved, except those selling it. Don’t take my word for it – here’s a list of outsourcing catastrophes for you to weep over. The point in this post is that the Fremantle-Catalyst endeavour was a Barnet council debacle to beat the band.

One Barnet

Unfortunately, that experience has not deterred the council from pursuing new and even bigger potential outsourcing disasters.

As we speak, the council nears a decision on the now-infamous (even before it is launched – not a good sign) One Barnet project – an amazingly unpopular plan to pay private companies the best part of £1bn to provide a mass of council services. There’s £275m up for grabs for development and regulatory services and a whopping £750m for a new, if ill-defined, support and customer services “organisation” from which services like council estates, finance, human resources, IT and revenues and benefits will, allegedly,  spring. In the face of monumental opposition from residents, five legendary local bloggers, an extremely motivated and informed union branch secretary and council staff and union members, the council will, on December 6, decide which (very lucky) private company will win the £750m contract. The second contract will be awarded in January.

The scale of the proposed private sector entanglement terrifies people – recent scandals like the G4S Olympic security failure demonstrated a) how spectacularly private companies can fail to meet obligations and b) that in the end, you need the public sector to come in and clean up the crap.

And One Barnet could be a very big turd indeed. Estimates are that 70% of the council’s services could be tied up in ten-year contracts with the private sector if One Barnet gets the green light. Unison expects hundreds of job losses as a result of outsourcing and “efficiency savings” – the sort of numbers that can only have a negative impact on services.

Pointed questions have also been asked about Barnet’s ability to keep a grip on all or even some of its relationships and contracts with private companies. I’ve already talked about the Fremantle-Catalyst wreck. Last year, there was another scandal, when Barnet bloggers revealed that the council had spent more more than £1m to hire a private security firm company called MetPro. The council engaged the firm without putting the contract out to tender, or running basic security and financial checks. I had the pleasure of that firm myself at a very feisty (ie full of pissed-off locals being denied the right to attend the meeting by overzealous private security guards) 2011 Barnet council budget cuts meeting. Security guards confiscated our laptops and cameras, bullied people who wanted to sit in on the public council meeting and overrode police decisions to let members of the public into chambers.

So.

There are just a few weeks left before Barnet council decides on that first major One Barnet contract. The council could hardly be in worse shape for it. Chief Executive Nick Walkley resigned at the beginning of October. Jury’s out on that one – depending who you talk to, that was either a great career move, or a running jump off the sinking ship (the two probably go hand in hand). A week or so ago, council leader Richard Cornelius faced a no-confidence vote.  Then controversial (many other words work as well) councillor Brian Coleman publicly slammed One Barnet as an “officer-driven juggernaut” and a turkey which needed to see Christmas. Only this week, a disabled woman has started legal proceedings against the council, saying that One Barnet does not give due regard to the needs of disabled people. Now, the fabulous Mr Mustard has published the impressive (as in size) One Barnet risk register.

And if you think Cornelius has lost control now – just wait until he signs off on this thing. There won’t be many people looking to make it work.

Why not to privatise…

Residents in Barnet have made this brilliant short animation to explain the risks associated with Barnet council’s plans to go ahead with its massive, and massively unpopular, one-billion pound outsourcing deal.

As many people will know, Barnet residents, bloggers and unions have been fighting the council’s plans to mass privatise council services (a plan called One Barnet). Already, they’ve won a fight to keep the council’s waste and recycling services in house.

Meeting tonight – a “Question Time” in Barnet on the One Barnet outsourcing programme
Tonight (Thursday 8 November at 7pm at the Greek Cypriot Centre, Britannia Road, London N12 9RU) Barnet residents will hold a ‘Question Time’ debate about the proposed One Barnet programme. On the panel will be Barnet resident and chair, Barbara Jacobson, Barnet Conservative Council Leader, Richard Cornelius, Labour Leader, Alison Moore, Lib Dem Leader Jack Cohen and Andy Mudd from the Association for Public Service Excellence.

Many people will know that it’s all hit the fan in a very big way over that mass-outsourcing deal. Council CE Nick Walkley recently resigned – only a couple of months before the mass-privatisation decision was due to be made. Everyone else is fighting – so this evening’s meeting could be a belter.

Top job done there by residents, bloggers and union members who have simply refused to accept that the private sector is entitled to their money and services. Hope they win.

Greece, hospitals, healthcare and cuts: Interview 7

Olga KosmopoulouAs the general strike continues in Greece, we publishing more transcripts from interviews we recorded last week with people who are dealing directly with cuts and austerity in Athens. Earlier interviews are posted in sequence below this one.

This post is a transcript from a recorded interview with Olga Kosmopoulou, a doctor who specialises in  infectious diseases , including HIV medicine. She works at the General Hospital of Nikaia.

In this interview, she talks about the problems her patients are facing, the political and economic situation in Greece and how this relates to health care and possible solutions for the future.

Speaking about her patients
“I would like to speak on behalf of my HIV patients.

Most of them live in this area, which is one of the poorest in Greece. Not everyone has free access to medicines and free access to healthcare. They have a lot of problems, which have increased over the last three years.

Problem number one: most of them are already stigmatised. It’s not easy for them to find a job. All these patients used to live on a benefit which was cut down. So, I know when I see some of them, they are going to face hunger during the winter. Some of them are going to be homeless during the winter.

Some of my patients are IV drug users. During the last three years, we have had an epidemic of HIV disease in IV drug users. Many are homeless and almost none are insured. We don’t have many social workers and many people who come here cannot be insured at all. They come here and say ‘please keep me in the hospital because I need a roof over my head, and food’, but I cannot do it for everybody.

The state has destroyed rehabilitation programmes. They say that we are doing better, but in fact, the places where people can find methadone are full. They don’t have enough doctors, not enough nurses, not enough psychiatrists and not enough support in general. They don’t even give syringes. On the other hand, the poverty among families made most of these people practice prostitution, which led to a very sudden rise in HIV.

All Greeks have seen their income diminish, but among them, the most frail patients with chronic diseases are desperate right now. They have to pay just to get into the hospital. They have to pay for a prescription. They have to pay part of the cost of their medicine. Sometimes, they don’t find the medicine they used to take, or they are forced to take another medicine by another company.

If people are diagnosed with HIV, they do have access to drug treatment. But, there is a frightening situation, because every time I ask for tablets, I have to refer the patient and the drug companies answer ‘”e approve the scheme, but we warn you that it is your responsibility to advise the patient to get insured.” But, the patient is not able to get insured. There is no insurance for most Greek people at the moment. There are well over 1 million people unemployed… and they are uninsured.

There are no preventative measures, like condoms. Of course not. It’s a joke. Non-governmental organisations may provide syringes and support. This is not correct. The state should organise this.

I don’t think anyone has time to find out which neighbourhoods are being particularly affected. To show you the size of the problem in Greek society, in this corner [points to corner of the room] last year, every month we collected food. We provided this food to schools in a poor area ,as the teachers were asking for food for children and their families. Last year, this corner was always full with food, and now, starting from September onwards, I haven’t been able to collect anything because they have cut down the salaries of the people.

The insecurity they feel makes them reluctant to help others. Although there is solidarity in Greek society, it’s going to have an end and this is the proof. Middle class people and poorer people are not able to help each anymore in the same way they used to. The food is running out. Philanthropy cannot be the solution.

The other disease that is increasing is suicides. We never had a high rate of suicide in Greece, because the weather is so good and family bonds are so close, so people felt secure. Now, we have a high rate of suicide, a high rate of psychiatric diseases, a high rate of depression. There are too many people taking tablets. On the other hand, psychiatric patients with severe illnesses have had their benefits cut down and they don’t have money, not even for cigarettes. The places where they used to stay are closed. So many of them are homeless. It’s really cold over winter, starting in November, through to early March. You can die on the street.

I see about 10 people everyday on the ward, sometimes 20 a day, sometimes 30 a day. When I work in casualty, we see more – about 300 a day at the general medical hospital.

In outpatient clinics, people come to get examined. Sometimes, I substitute for social workers… everything.

On treating everybody
This is a special place because in my way, I am a political person. I see immigrants. I treat people [who do not have] papers. I see everybody without asking for the fee of €5. Me and my colleagues have been downstairs several times to stop patients paying.

On Golden Dawn
I hope I will never meet them. They don’t dare to get into the hospitals yet. But they have declared that they are going to come to the hospitals and take the immigrants – they mean every foreigner – and get them out of the hospitals. But, of course, outside the hospital, there are a lot of Pakistani people living in this area. They have been beaten several times by Golden Dawn. They are legal immigrants.

On solutions and the future
There is no future inside the European Union. The EU doesn’t express the will of the people of Europe. It expresses the will of bankers. I don’t think there is any future inside this European Union. I think the problem is for the whole of Europe, not just Greece. Greece is just a kind of experiment. It was very easy to say ‘oh you’re Greek, you’re lazy,’ which is not true. That makes other people take in what was happening to us without saying anything.

We have two solutions. We can either accept it and go into the darkest years of history, or we do not accept this. I am very, very afraid, because I would not like to live in such times. I am very afraid that people will need their own revolution to get power again. If they don’t, they are going to live in very, very dark years. People in Greece have to take power in their hands.

They don’t have this power by voting. The politicians threatened us [during the last elections, with] -‘if you don’t vote for us, we are going to have to leave the Euro’, which is funny. If you don’t have any money, you don’t really care whether its drachma or euro or anything. I firmly believe that without revolutionary methods…I don’t mean violence – but people in Greece, and other countries like Greece, have to understand that its very important to go radical.

Affected personally
This is like a thunderstorm. We have seen our lives change to such a degree that sometimes, I don’t have money for the mortgage anymore. This means that I would be without a house. My brother and sister and their children would also be without a house [they live together now]. It is not only me – this is a whole family.

An [example of an everyday danger/worry is] – I think – “do I have enough gasoline to go to the hospital?” because public transport doesn’t help. I need two hours for that. To make time for my patients, I need to use my car. We are a middle class family – in wintertime, we decided that we wouldn’t use any heat in the house, except for the bedrooms and the place where the kids study. And we are doing well compared to others. Most people in Athens will not have enough heat during the winter. My salary has been cut by 40% and now they are going cut it by another 20%, from a salary that was about 50% or 60% that of a medical specialist to begin with.

From Greece: a generation of young immigrants who’ll hate Europe like hell. Interviews 4,5,6

This is another transcript from the recorded interviews Abi and I made last week in Greece.

This transcript is from a recording made last week with three young men – all recent immigrants – in Greece. Two were from Togo and one from Nigeria. There’s an audio from that interview here:

We spoke to the three men at a centre and cafe where free Greek language lessons are held for immigrants. All three had paid agents for transport and help getting into Greece (through Turkey) and all had been promised that they’d be able to study and work in Athens. None had been able to get a job and none had been able to get papers to stay or to study.

All three had been either abused or physically attacked by the police – one of the men, Koffi, 25, pointed to a large lump and cut above his eye where, a few days earlier, he’d been hit by a bottle that the police had thrown at him. Two of the young men were planning to leave Greece as soon as they had the money together.

So. They will return to Togo and Nigeria without their money and with an utter loathing of Europe – something Angela Merkel and cronies might want to keep in mind. There was a certain nationalism forming in the minds of these young men: a nationalism based in part on a feeling that home was considerably more civilised and sophisticated than Europe and in part on a fury at Europe’s vile treatment of them. Could be interesting for Europe, if this generation of young, rejected immigrants decides on revenge when it comes of age.

Saheed Aylula, aged 22. Home country: Nigeria. Has been living in Greece for three years.

“The reason why I came to this country is for education. I’ve been here for three years.

In my country, I studied accounting. I believed that when I came here would continue with my education and pay for myself with a part time job. Unfortunately, I found out that was impossible for me. I’ve been to many place to look for a job – to look at something I can do to finance myself, so that I can continue my education. They give us a form to fill in and say that we will call you when we need people.

I tried many, many cafes, so that maybe they can employ me, but unfortunately, none of them can give me a job.

So, I started to sell something.

[I have been] selling photographs and posters. Sometimes, that sells and sometimes I can’t [sic]. [Then] one of my friends told me that there is a school where I can learn Greek here for free, so I came to here and [I’m] learning Greek. Before, I cannot speak any Greek. And the people you want to sell something to – you want to talk with them before they buy something from you. Unfortunately, I would say [to them] – would you speak English? and they would say No, only Greek. So, it was very difficult for me to communicate with them and that’s why I’m learning Greek.

To be frank, I cannot stay here.

If I had known how this place has been, I wouldn’t have come. This country is a … I think I need to go back to my country, because there’s no room for [me to develop here]. You can’t get any benefit from here. There’s no job. There’s no future. So, I’m planning to go back to my country.

In Nigeria, we have corruption, but I think Nigeria is better than here. If I don’t have papers to move forward, there is no way I can proceed to another country [in Europe]. [Anyway] – I’m seeing that all of Europe is having an economic crisis. Even moving to another European country… I don’t know what I can do there. I can’t believe that I will face a problem like this there.

I came alone. My family is still in Nigeria, but one of my brothers is in Canada. So, the others of my family are in Nigeria.

We are facing many problems here. First of all – they don’t like foreigners. Just take a look. If I’m on the bus, I can not get people to sit down with me. If there is two seats there, I cannot get people to sit next to me. You can go to any restaurant or any cafe here and you cannot see blacks working there. They don’t like the foreigners. They don’t like the blacks. That’s what I said – you can go to many restaurants, many cafes and many shops and you cannot see blacks working there. I didn’t expect it to be like that. That’s why I’m going back to my country. I can settle down and enjoy my family. I cannot see a future here.

The police? – countless times the police have been racist to me. A friend of mine, three or four months ago now – the guy was macheted. They [the perpetrators] were wearing black. They macheted the guy around nine or 10pm. So, that’s the reason why I don’t feel like walking around at night.

The police – [they’ll say] – ah, excuse me, can I see your passport? And they [do this]… [makes a gesture to demonstrate someone flicking someone else in the face]. That was,…the fury. We cannot wait for two minutes before they are stopping you. Many people in the bus stop – they will say if you don’t have a passport, you cannot stay here. So, that’s why I’m saying maybe I would not be able to live in another country. Maybe it’s better for me to go back to my country.

It’s worse now than it was [three years ago] when I came here.

Of course I am scared here. I live in Pagrati. I live with my friend. My friend is from Nigeria as well. He is finding it difficult as well. He is not working. I haven’t worked for a single day since I got here. I’m selling things – that’s how I buy food. It’s not enough. I regret coming to Europe.

For me….they don’t believe that foreigners or immigrants have…brains or can share anything. They don’t believe that immigrants are intelligent.

When you’re selling the photographs, the police will stop you – the municipal police. They move you around. They can arrest you.

I’ve spoken to my parents. They also call me and they say come back. My father is a businessman and my mother is working on a farm. They have got good jobs. They are not so rich and they are not so poor. They are in the middle.”

Koffi, aged 25. Home country: Togo. Has been in Greece for three months.

“I came here for education. I was studying economics. I wanted to learn Greek and English. I wanted to finish my schooling. That’s why I came here.

The police attack us every day. It’s been very difficult. We don’t have time [the chance] to work to get money. We don’t have time [the chance] to get out to learn the language. The police stop us every day. They attack you.

They know us… they know if you don’t have the papers. They hunt you like you are a thief or something. [They] bring us to the station to ask if you have the papers. Why? They have you go to the police station before they even ask you to see your papers. They don’t like to see the black [sic]. Why? Why don’t want to see the black? In other countries, they like black people. In Africa, we treat white people like us.

We collect bottles to sell to recycling. Sometimes, you get just two euros in a day to survive. [People collect bottles, then put them in recycling machines for a few euros].

[I live with] 15 people together in Victoria.

I thought Europe would be a good area – a place that it would be easy for me to go to school, to learn something good. I’m not able to study here, because we don’t have a chance to meet people to learn.

[I don’t want to go home]. I want to fight and to let them know that the immigrants can contribute.

I want to learn Greek. I want to go to school here. It is very hard for people who don’t go to school.

I would go back home, but in life – everybody wants to be the best, to have a good life. I’m here to learn, to know something, to get knowledge – but [given] the conditions, it is not possible.”

Eden, aged 27. Home country: Togo. Has been in Greece for ten months.

“I wanted to continue my studies. I study history.

It’s a little bit difficult. They don’t tell you the real situation with the country that you’re going to face. So they [agents] help you get here and when you get here, you find the reality. It’s crazy.

Me – I was thinking that when I got here, I would have a time [when I got] a paper to be registered in a university, but when I got here, I realise that I had to go get a pink card. It’s called a pink card – it’s a refuge card. It’s not an easy deal to get one. There’s a fight here every time to get one.

For me, I left my country – normally, the person [someone looking to emigrate to Greece from Africa] will pay to get there. To pay, you take a plane to Turkey and then you come here by boat or something like that. It cost €3000 – paid that to an agent to get here. They say it’s going to be great – you can go to school, you can get a job…

It’s really hard being here. You have to face it. Because the police – the big problem is the police. They are harassing [us]. If you are in the danger zones – some parts are really dangerous.

I’m not going to stay I’m waiting for the end of the year to go back to my country. I have finished my studying in Togo – I have learned African history and done design also. So – I wanted, after learning Greek, to complete my design skills.

But there are no human rights here. You don’t see them here.

The police are very racist.

Koffi says: There is no human rights. The way the police behave with people – they don’t treat you like you’re human. There’s nobody to help. At home – it’s your country, you’re more relaxed. You don’t have any problem in that country.

Eden: It’s just like a lot of grief. I’m looking forward to going home. I hear that the pink card does not allow you to go to the university [anyway]. I don’t consider myself as a refugee.

Koffi says – This place that you go to get the pink card – this is the place that I have this problem (points to the injury on his head). The police threw a gas bottle. I don’t have this pink card. It’s where we queue for the pink cards.

Cuts and segregation: Athens and the UK

A report by me and Abi in the New Statesman today on our recent experiences in Athens:

“Dead-eyed, austerity continues to march Europe deeper into poverty, shock, fascism and other forms of oblivion. Reporting that and the wider experience is a crucial part of the response of those of us who refuse to accept that most people exist to serve out as austerity’s fodder. To put it another way – everyone everywhere needs to know when and where poverty and fascism are taking people out across Europe and anyone who is in a position to report that should be doing so. So, we went to Athens last week.

Right away, race was an issue. Abi: “I spoke to Greeks in London who told of anarchist friends being beaten up alongside immigrants. Before we left, I’d heard that the American government issued a statement warning dark-skinned Americans in Athens to be careful when leaving their hotels at night. I assumed that as a dark-skinned British person, that probably applied to me as well.

Many of the Greek people we met wondered why the UK government was pursuing cuts with such passion off its own bat. A dentist we spoke to said: “In Greece the Troika is forcing us to implement these cuts. In the UK, your own government is doing it. Why?” Certainly, the evils being inflicted on people in the UK in the name of bank bailouts and corporate welfare – the Atos assessments, care cuts, bedroom taxes, council tax benefit cuts, housing benefit caps, rocketing rents, workfare, falling wages, the relying on foodbanks and all the rest – often came to mind while we were in Athens. The rise and rise of Golden Dawn may not be replicated here, but the heaping of cuts and blame on people who can least afford to shoulder those things sure as hell is.”

Full article here.

“I don’t mind the Golden Dawn. They are young and they are Greek.” Interview 3

Photo: Christos Mpampouras. By Abi Ramanan, Athens, October 2012.

This is the third transcript from the recorded interviews Abi Ramanan and I made in Athens last week. We interviewed people there about the economic crisis, service cuts and the rise of fascism. We’re publishing transcripts from the recorded interviews we made on this site over the next week.

There’s more background and the first interview (with a Golden Dawn voter called Kelly) is here.

The second interview with highschool teacher Pavlos Antonopoulos is here.

This is a transcript of a recorded interview with Christos Mpampouras, 61. He is a drummer and was a farmworker. He told us that he has a small farmworkers’ pension. He is originally from Ipeiros and now lives in Athens. He visits the municipal soup kitchen in Omonoia twice a day for meals. There were hundreds of people queuing for lunch when we went to the soup kitchen at about midday on Friday 26 October. Many of the people in the queue were elderly.

On needing the soup kitchen
I’ve been coming here for about five years, for two meals a day. I have very good relations with the people who work here. If they need help with shipping or unloading things, I help out.

It used to be that maybe about 250 Greeks came here, but now it’s probably increased to 500 people for each meal. A lot people really need it, but there are also people who don’t need it. Most of the people who come for food are older people like me, but there are also a lot of young people who are drug addicts. There is no reason why they should come.

I used to work part-time with my drums. There wasn’t a lot of work and my [farmworkers’] pension is one of the lowest in Greece. A friend brought me here [to the soup kitchen]. I don’t have my own house in Athens. I rented one before the crisis. After that, I didn’t make enough money to pay the rent, so now I’m staying with a friend temporarily. Of the 500 regulars I know who go to the soup kitchen, maybe 100 have their own house.

On the rise of the Golden Dawn
I don’t have a problem with the Golden Dawn, because they’re Greeks and they’re also young people and they don’t have work. I don’t think they’re fascists. I don’t know why people call them fascists. The politician [communist party MP Liana Kanelli] who got slapped on television [by Golden Dawn MP Ilias Kasidiaris] – I liked her and I used to vote for the Communist party myself, but she was very provocative on that television show. I think she was calling him a fascist, so it was not surprising that he got angry. The Golden Dawn – they’re not that bad. They haven’t hurt me and they’re Greeks and they’re young.

On immigration
I’m okay with people coming from Syria, or Iraq, because they have war, but I can’t understand why people come from Albania and take my job and my pension. Albanians – go to Albania. Go to your country instead of here. I’m not a racist. An Albanian comes here, makes some money which in his country is a lot of money. He makes a fortune. If I work for five months, I won’t make that sort of money.

Drugs in Omonoia
There are lots of people here on drugs. They sell the drugs in matchboxes. Mostly, the black people sell them, but sometimes, when the police come, they give the matchboxes to Greeks because the police don’t search them. That means that the black people don’t get caught. When the police leave, they get back the drugs and they keep selling them. The blacks go [and wait] outside the hospitals for drug addicts, so that they can sell them drugs.

Everyone is responsible for the crisis, because everyone was living outside of their means. It is my fault as well, because I didn’t save enough money before the crisis. My father in the village used to have a phrase which roughly translated says “the river doesn’t always bring wood.” You can’t always expect the river to bring wood and now the river is no longer bringing wood.

I’m 61 years old and I won’t receive the pension I’m entitled to until I’m 65. I thought that I would be all right until I was 65, but now I’m unemployed, because nobody will hire me at 61.

I have a son. We haven’t spoken in years because I was divorced. I don’t want to contact him and I don’t really have anyone in the family who I can seek out and talk to.

The food at the soup kitchen
The food is clean. Monday, they have lentil soup. Tuesday, it’s chicken. Wednesday, it’s fish. Sometimes, there’s meatballs, so there’s a variety. The food is good quality, but I can’t put as much salt in it as I want. You can’t go there and say – I want to put more salt and pepper in. It’s not like when you make your own food.

When there’s chicken, it finishes very quickly. Usually, there isn’t a problem, but if they have something nice, it goes very fast.

They had a lot of soup here. Soup is fine for the morning, but I don’t like it when they have soup in the evening, or for lunch. Soup is very little for lunch. You don’t feel like you’re eating. You eat more like a person in the church foodbank, because you can add oils and spices.

I told the fascists to leave the school and they said they’d stab me. Interview 2

Video: graffiti on a torched mosque and a school in Kallithea where teachers have been running antifascist campaigns:

Last week, I went to Athens with a friend called Abi Ramanan. We interviewed people there about the economic crisis, service cuts and the rise of fascism. We’re publishing transcripts from the recorded interviews we made on this site over the next week.

There’s more background and the first interview (with a Golden Dawn voter called Kelly) is here.

This post is a transcript with a teacher called Pavlos Antonopoulos. He has been a teacher for 30 years – the last 12 at an Athens highschool. He describes the neighbourhood and school catchment area as working-class. His students are aged between 15 and 17. He is also a well-known activist.

In this interview, he talks about the Golden Dawn’s increasingly bold attempts (the last one just three days before we met) to make contact with his students – to get into the school and to talk to students. He also talks about drastic cuts to school resources, the government’s plans to cut funds and the number of teachers further by merging Antonopoulos’ school with another and his belief that Greece and working people will only have any sort of future if the troika is foiled, austerity is abandoned and the country returns to the drachma:

On the growing confidence of the Golden Dawn:
“A few days ago, three older former students [one-time students of the school] – they were about 20 or 21 years old – they came into the school and were speaking with students.

The person who was on the school’s security door didn’t mind [that person let them in], so they came in. They may have been sympathetic to them. They may have been afraid. When I saw them, I asked them to go out [to leave]. Two weeks earlier, [they’d tried to get into the school] but when I asked them to leave, I was successful. They went out. [This time, though], three days ago, they argued when I told them to go out. They started to say many things. I threw them out, but when they were at the gate, they told the security person “we will take care of you”, but that they would stab me.

I went to the manager – the president of the school. I told him, but I don’t think he understood what I told him, so I went to the police station. I was lucky – because the police officer had a little girl who was a student in my school [so he knew me]. That was the only way [I got a hearing].

We had a big conversation about this and I asked him to bring the three young men to the police station to have a talk. I told him that I would go to court – so yesterday, he called me and I went there and he called the three there. We had a conversation – all of us. Of course – they said “we didn’t say those things. We didn’t mean it.” Some days before, the fascists had made an announcement that they would fire all teachers in the area who speak against fascism. We decided to speak in the classrooms against fascism, against the Golden Dawn and now, they try to stop us.

On food and books
[In] the last year, we noticed that many students didn’t have enough to eat. We had a meeting with a council of parents and they told us that in our school, they had about 15 cases like this, where the children didn’t have food. We tried to form a group to help them. Where I live, we have one union like this…Kids are swooning, because they don’t eat. We paid for the food ourselves – teachers and the other parents… We [also] give free lessons for the children that can’t pay. [When] we have demonstrations and strikes, we take the children. We try to make them fight against the situation.

Last year, we didn’t have books. It was the first time since the war that we didn’t have books. We made copies from all the books and gave them to children. Of course – that was more expensive than books, but they didn’t want to give money for books, so they pressed us to give money ourselves, from our pockets, to do photocopies.

[They are merging] two schools in our area – my school and another. This means many more children in the classroom now, because the school has merged. It’s part of the cuts. They merge schools into one with the same number of kids. They try to use less [sic] teachers, so they increase the number of pupils in the class. We lost about ten teachers as part of the merger in these two schools.

That is one thing. The second is that they cut our [teacher] salaries. They changed everything. A new teacher now takes about €580 per month. If you think that three years before, the salary was about €1000 – they’ve cut about half the salary. [Meanwhile prices go up]. For petrol – in two years, the price is has about doubled. Now, it is about €1.80 per litre for gas and now, to heat houses, it’s going to something like €1.40.

Leaving the Euro
We believe that this is the solution now for the working class – we have to leave the Euro, because we can’t make our own economic policies [while we’re in Europe]. They [the troika] use the threat that we’re going to go out of the Euro every time that they want to pass more austerity measures.

We can’t control our salaries, or our prices – nothing, because the Euro is stable. If your money supply is controlled by the EU, you can’t do anything. We have to change our policy. We have to start producing what we started closing several years before – clothing, sugar, the shipyards. We don’t produce anything now. We import. If it will continue in this way, we will collapse in two or three years.

Motivating students
The young people have lost their belief in the future, so it’s very difficult for us to make them focus on their lessons and to prepare for university, because they say – “we’re going to the university and after, we will not have jobs.” Most of them will look for a way to leave Greece. We try to force them to fight to change the situation. That means that they have to fight for their schools, for their books, for money for the schools.

They can’t find jobs. I have three children – one is 37, one is 34 and the youngest is 24. None of them works now. The first one lost his job two years ago. He’s tried to find a job everywhere, but he can’t find any job. The second is my girl. She has a degree in fine arts. She can’t find job anywhere. The last – he has a degree and he can’t find a job. My daughter has a boyfriend now and she wants to get married, but I said – forget it for the next ten years. There are too many problems.

On immigration
Immigration is a big problem, because Greece is the gate to Europe. Thousands of immigrants come to Greece, because they want to go to other parts of Europe. Of course [I understand why they want to come here]. The problem starts in their countries, because they are bombing. I went to Gaza some years ago when Israel was bombing it. I couldn’t believe that people could live in that situation. They were bombing from the air and tanks. I stayed a few days. I thought I was in hell. People can’t stay there.

They are trapped here – it’s a trap in Greece for them. Like in the second world war – they used the Jews [to blame for economic problems]. Now they use immigrants. We believe that the solution is first to give them papers. We have to recognise that they exist. Second – we have to open the borders and say to them “Go where you want.” For the immigrants who want to stay here – you have to give them places to stay.. Of course – they [austerity’s supporters] use them to make as scapegoats.

Greece, cuts, cruelty and voting for the Golden Dawn – interview 1

Audio recording of interview with Kelly, 27 October 2012: Why I voted for the Golden Dawn.

Last week, I went to Athens for several days with a friend called Abi Ramanan. We interviewed as many people as we could about the economic crisis, service cuts and the rise of fascism. We’ll be publishing a number of articles about the experience – we have one in particular that focuses on the racism and warnings about her safety that Abi had to contend with and that I – because I am white – did not. In some respects, our trip had an air of segregation about it.

Abi first called me in about March this year to suggest the trip. She’d just visited Athens, where she’d been interviewing people about the appalling results of austerity there. She knew that I was interviewing people around the UK who were on the sharp end of this government’s cuts – people who were losing care services, benefits, homes and any hope of rescue – and wanted to know if I’d join her on another visit to Athens, to talk to more people and compare cuts stories from Greece with cuts stories in the UK.

I thought that idea had plenty of merit. Making contacts across the continent and swapping notes and plans for fightback seemed a sensible move, particularly as austerity continues to march Europe deeper into poverty, shock, fascism and other forms of oblivion. Reporting that and the wider experience is a crucial part of the response of those of us who refuse to accept that most people exist to serve out as austerity’s fodder. To put it another way – everyone everywhere needs to know when and where poverty and fascism are taking people out across Europe and anyone who is in a position to report that should be doing so.

On this site, we’re publishing transcripts of the recorded interviews we made in Athens. We have about ten to post, which we’ll do over the next few days. We’ll add links to our other articles as they appear. We’ll also be adding the audios from the interviews when we’ve had time to upload them.

This first interview is with Kelly, 31. We met her last Saturday. She voted for the Golden Dawn in the recent elections and plans to vote for them again. She explains why in this interview.

Kelly studied communications and works in telecommunications for four to six hours a day. She earns around €400 a month, plus commission. She also works as a stylist. She lives in Kallithea with her parents and her brother. 

On the political situation, paying the bills and trying to find work:
“I am pessimistic. [There are] many problems. The working class is suffering, I was living a lie. My parents, my tutors and the system told me how my life would be and I realised it wasn’t true.

I don’t know how to get through this and live the rest of my years. I feel it was all a lie because I can’t have the work I think I deserve. I can’t have a family. The crisis isn’t only economic. We don’t believe in things now – it is also a crisis of confidence. The political situation isn’t only in our pockets with work. It’s in our minds – we can’t trust anyone anymore.

Depression, anger, [the fact that] we can’t make dreams is a common feeling, especially among young people in Greece.

[I believe] that the situation has been caused the socialist party of George Papandreou – they took advantage of the good circumstances in the previous period and as a result this generation has to suffer.

On the appeal of the Golden Dawn
“I’m not here to say Golden Dawn are good. I’m here to explain the intention of the Golden Dawn voter. I don’t have a problem with immigrants. If an immigrant came to my house and wanted to eat, I’ll be the first person to give him food. I’m very generous and all Greek people are too – they will help anyone.

But I believe that I would prefer to vote for a party that says [things like] – “you know what? I’m the worst. I’m a fascist” – but [at least] are honest and straightforward in what they do. Not like the other parties who say – “I’ll increase your salary and your unemployment benefit will increase”, which are all lies. I appreciate the fact that Golden Dawn members are very straightforward and don’t want parliamentary salaries, but normal ones.

Golden Dawn is also against the memorandum and the most important reason for their appeal is because it’s a stroke [a hit] against the other political parties. It’s revenge. I believe that Golden Dawn is an extreme party, but I believe that the political system is a jungle and is also extreme. The existing system is pro-austerity.

The worst thing in Greek society is the cultivating media that misleads Greek people. For example, they say that Golden Dawn is anti-immigration, but at the same time, they are selling the country. So, to mislead [divert] us, they tell us about Golden Dawn, but the situation is more complex than that. They are cultivating us. They use Golden Dawn as a means to divide people.

I would not like to see a government with Golden Dawn as the main political party. I feel they should be in opposition, because I’m a little bit afraid of them. Even though I can understand the intention of someone to vote for Golden Dawn, I’m not sure that they should be government. Also, I don’t believe any political party can lead Greece out of this crisis. Only going back to the drachma will solve this. At first there will be a slump but in the future we will grow again.

In every party, there are bad people. When there is a protest in Syntagma, some anarchists will take advantage and start to burn the city, in Golden Dawn, there are some – not fascists, but psychos who will take advantage of situations. I’m afraid and a little bit concerned of what comes out of them, with all the news of attacks on immigrants. It’s more extreme than what I thought, but, if there were elections now, I would vote for Golden Dawn again.

On Golden Dawn’s attacks on immigrants
I don’t believe that all the stories are real. But, one day on the bus, there was a big man who started shouting at an immigrant – “get off the bus!” and “get your legs down!” and things like that. I freaked out. That makes me angry. But – I have had situations in the last year [with immigrants that I’ve had to deal with]. I went out for a walk at 11 o’clock at night. There was a man – a Russian or something like that – in his car. He was in the car with a junkie. They had a fight and the junkie got out and started to scream, I waited for a bit and then started to walk.

The driver saw me. He started following me inside the car. He started speaking to me – he kind of blocked my way two times with his car. It seemed like he was coming out of the car and maybe to try to grab me in an assault. I started to run and luckily my house was only ten seconds from this place. There is a problem in Greece – the immigrants here don’t want a better future. They don’t want to work and make families. They are from jails, they are engaging with crime, they are not civilised people. They rape [and] they are thieves. Not all the immigrants – but a lot of the immigrants here are like this. I know this from my own personal experience and from various other incidents. This is not from the media, but from my friends and people I know. Not from the media.

I am against Golden Dawn going into schools and hospitals, but, I also condemn the mainstream media for not giving them equal publicity to other political parties. They have no space in the media and so they have to go from door to door to spread their message and communicate their ideas.

Some of them are fascists but some of them aren’t. I am not a fascist person.”

On the past, friends, family and the drachma
I didn’t follow politics when I was younger. In Greece, when you support a party, you get some benefits [from that] – work and so on, so maybe I should do it, but I prefer to vote for Golden Dawn. I have always lived in Athens and I don’t think I want to leave, even with [the economic] situation. I believe that Greek people are very generous and very polite. We have a good energy. I have travelled to some countries and I believe that believe Greek people are the best.

The majority of people oppose the drachma policy – they say things will get worse and worse. I know people who have voted for Golden Dawn, who are like me, who are not fascist people, and other parties are criticising them again and again. The real fascist people are the other parties. I would never call someone a fascist for what they believe in.

[My friends are] considering leaving Greece, but we none of us want to leave. We love our country. To go away you have to have money and you need work. It is more difficult. Around ten percent of my friends are interested in Golden Dawn.

My parents find the situation very difficult. They feel sad about our generation and the dreams they had for their children, the destruction of the healthcare system and the reduction of pensions. They did not vote for Golden Dawn. I am the black sheep of the family. They understand why I did vote for them though. They didn’t criticise me.

 

Hartlepool, actors and singers, and the bedroom tax

These are the latest excerpts from recorded interviews I’m publishing as I talk to people around the country who are dealing with fallout from public sector cuts, welfare reform and the recession. These transcripts are from interviews with actors, singers and writers at Shoot Your Mouth Off films – a filmmaking project in Hartlepool for people with learning disabilities.

In the transcripts, people talk about their work as actors, singers and writers.

The people who spoke for the interviews were David Miller, Carole Gill, David Lodge, Daniel Judge, Liz Yeats, Graeme Booth and Wendy Elsley.

Photos by @skinnyvoice at deptfordvisions.com.

People here are dealing with many issues: Karen Sheader, the disability rights activist who set SYMO up, says, for example, that two people in the group are worried that they will be affected by the proposed bedroom tax. The two people live by themselves in two-bedroom flats and are concerned that they will either have to move to one-bedroom flats (if they’re available) or lose part of their benefits. There’s a lot of confusion and worry:

“It does make you wonder where they think people are going to to get the money from, especially those people who are already on benefits. There are a couple of people in our group who live in two bedroom flats who were allocated the flats by the local authority who are now being told that they might have to be moved to a one bedroom flat because of the changes to housing benefit.

“Peter (one of the people who is in a two-bedroom flat) came in (one day) with a letter and he didn’t understand it, because he can’t read. It was about his council tax benefit and his housing benefit and he was panicking. When he got this letter, I rang [the council officer] and she offered to see Peter to reassure him. She was saying this is not going to happen in the immediate future – this (the letter) was just saying that it might happen at some point in the future.”

Some people in the group are on benefits, while others work in other jobs, too: Wendy Elsley and Graeme Booth, for example, both work part-time at Asda.

I’ll be posting more on this soon. In the meantime, here are some thoughts from people involved in Shoot Your Mouth Off films. Videos to follow.

Graeme Booth
“I’ve got to work two days a week (at Asda), so I’m here on a Monday now. I swapped days over, so I could come back and make films. The best film I’ve done is Dr Why with Wendy. It was just a Dr Who spoof, really. We did it all in front of a green screen. [In the end], I got done in by a big plastic dinosaur.”

David Miller
“I’ve been at Shoot Your Mouth Off films from the start, for five years. When we first came, there were no tables, no chairs – just boxes to sit on. Some of us have got bands in it as well. I’ve got a band called Friends Forever and my friend Daniel Judge over there, he does rapping. He’s going solo now as well. Hope Springs [a soap] is the film I enjoyed the most. The other one I love is called Maniac Mum. It’ll be done for the Christmas show.

Daniel Judge
My name is Daniel Judge, but really my name is… Dr Judge. I’m a musician…and with a good friend of mine. Coming into SYMO has changed my life. All my friends are in here. My heroes too. I’ve been coming here quite a long time. By 2007 – that’s the year when I did a new group with a certain guy called Mr Miller over here – Big Daddy Cool. And I produced the album called Rise to Fame and I was on the radio, Radio Hartlepool.

David Lodge
My name is David Lodge and I’ve been coming to SYMO for just over a year. Acting’s been part of my life [since I was young]. I went to college for four years and did drama and got qualifications. The best way to describe myself is as an all rounder – acting singing as well. I’ve just played the devil in Nuts To You. A couple of weeks ago, it was on Northeast Tonight, which is our local news for the region. Everybody – from my girlfriend to my Mum and Dad and other people have said I’ve seen you on the TV. Even people are coming up three weeks on have seen it. Acting’s been my passion.

Carole Gill
I’ve only been coming here for seven months, since Easter. I like singing and acting and I like to come here, because everybody’s friendly and made me welcome when I came in. I’m in Maniac Mum. I love singing.

I do get nervous…[before our last show] it was terrible. I couldn’t eat nowt. I did it, though. I wouldn’t let them down anyway. When I heard that there was a group called SYMO, I came with one of our staff members. I thought it would be the right thing for me to do and so I wanted to join. Everybody made me welcome and they give us a cup of tea and made me feel that I felt was at home. My best part was when I was singing live music. We had about 150 people in the room. I sang One Moment In Time and Karen was playing it on the synthesiser.

Wendy Elsley
I used to come here on a Friday, but I stopped coming in on a Friday, because I’m working in Asda now and they swapped my days. So I had to finish this film off – otherwise they would have been up the creek without a paddle. I’d worked really hard with it and finished it off. [That was] Nuts To You.

I do adult literacy [classes]. In Asda, I’m doing all the clothes work in the clothes department. We start round about nine o’clock and then we have our dinners around about 12 o’clock and then we have two breaks between ten and three, so it’s been a long day but it goes very quick. I’ve been there quite a while now – 20 years now in Asda. I just get on with what I’ve been told to get on with.

With the [adult literacy classes] – Karen helped me [find one]. I met this new tutor and she is dead lovely. She said – what do you want to do? and I said – I want to learn to read. I want to read and write, because if I don’t read and write, that’s it – my brain is totally switched off. I love reading and writing. My Mum says my reading has improved a lot from what is used to be and it’s helped me with my acting as well because I can read scripts as well.

I just love coming here. If I wasn’t coming here now, I’d just be sitting at home 24-7, so I’m looking for something else to do on a Tuesday. I like art, making cards and stuff.

Liz Yeats
I come here on a Monday. I prefer Mondays than Fridays, because I seem to get on better on on a Monday. I’ve got lots of friends on a Monday, because I love everybody. That’s why I’m here for. And I’m best at drama and I’m a good comedian. I just like to join in.

DPAC protestors block Park Lane 20 October 2012

While Ed Miliband yabbered on about hard choices and the facts of life and some cuts being unavoidable (we could hear him in the background)…protestors from Disabled People Against Cuts chained their wheelchairs together and shut down Park Lane at the Marble Arch end at today’s TUC march.

I’ll upload more video later today and tomorrow. This one shows the blockade and also the stopped traffic. A protestor argues the case for the action with a copper at the end. After a while, the police worked out that the protestors weren’t going to move and were forced to make all the vehicles on Park Lane – buses included – turn around.

If only Miliband had encouraged the rest of the march to join DPAC and Boycott Workfare in shutting streets and shops across London down. Too hard a choice, perhaps.