The bedroom tax, austerity and death by the political class

As some people know, I write about public sector cuts, so-called “welfare reform” and spend a lot of time talking with people who are on the receiving end of evil shit like the bedroom tax, social care cuts, Atos assessments and so on and so forth.

As some people also know, I’m getting to the end of my tether with it – not the talking with people, which I like, because we sit down for ages and talk about all kinds of things, but the appalling indifference of the political class to the realities of the destruction of social security (and you only need to read this Mirror story to get that). I think I’m witnessing powderkeg situations which are causing people stress that they won’t be able to cope with forever. This couple I’m talking with – we’re in contact every few days now – can’t cope. They’re having to pay the bedroom tax, they’re having to pay council tax now their benefit has been cut and they must also attend Atos assessments. They literally get a letter, or a payment demand, every week. This woman, Mary Laver, made quite clear to me that she’d consider suicide if the money that pays for her carers is cut. But the political class doesn’t give a shit. Nobody listens. Nobody who has the power to make change cares enough to speak out for it. I’m really fucking sick of that. I’m sick of a bloody commentariat which, with a few honourable exceptions, writes of the destruction of social security as though it is utterly inevitable and as though there was just one point in history (the few years after the second world war) when it was possible for politicians to advocate for social security and that we will never have that sort of chance or time again.

I’m sick of knowing that politicians across the spectrum believe that the fight for social security has been lost and has been lost forever, and that it is perfectly acceptable to view anyone who uses health, care, education or housing services as political collateral. I also hate the kind of journalist I’ve become against this appalling austerity backdrop. I feel that I’ve got to a point where I’m acting in too gratuitous a manner: that I’m here to gawp and to offer people up for others to gawp at, so that well-appointed members of the chattering classes can shake their heads and cluck their tongues and say ISN’T THIS GOVERNMENT TERRIBLE and OH LOOK AT THOSE POOR POOR PEOPLE and tweet a bit and then do fuck all about it. I think that I’m making people look pathetic when they are not pathetic. They’re being pushed into a corner and Labour isn’t prepared to fight that corner for them, but that doesn’t make them pathetic. That makes them people who have no political representation. That’s a very dangerous place to be. People who are in that place are totally exposed.

Anyway – I’ve decided to start posting more of the conversations, calls and discussions that I have with people who are going through all this and also some of the conversations that I have with officialdom so that people can see how fucked up so much of this cuts scene is and how real the agonies are. I want people to see how the average day goes.

And here is an average day from last week. I’m writing this one first because it will give you a good idea of the shit that is being talked to journalists as housing associations and their hangers-on try to justify the implementation of the appalling bedroom tax. And yes – I know that officers are struggling with this and have been put in a position where they must implement this dreadful thing, or compromise their own jobs and incomes. However – that is, in my view, an aspect to the thing that housing associations use to justify their own awful political line:

I got out of bed last Tuesday and took the dog for a walk and then I came back and that’s when it all started to kick off. My phone rang (I was expecting it to, but I watched it thrash around for a bit). It was a senior-ish person from the South Liverpool Housing Group – a housing association which is imposing the bedroom tax on tenants who have a so-called spare room.

I stayed in Liverpool for a while in March and met lots of different people who were, at that point, faced with the prospect of paying the tax. At that stage, they were still half-hoping that someone would intervene on their behalf (Liverpool city councillors and/or Ed Miliband, I guess, although they might as well have sent their prayers up to bloody Tinkerbell for all the return they got on that. Everybody knew it was useless. Everybody knew it was useless, because not a single councillor turned up to the bedroom tax meetings that were being held then to offer support. People absolutely knew then they’d been cast adrift). None of those people did intervene on their behalf, of course (I don’t count the Labour councillor flag-waving and handwringing at the March 16 protests as intervention – any politicking bellend with an hour to spare and an eye to the main chance can wave his or her hands and a placard around and say “fuck me – aren’t Tories mean”).

So now, the people I met are actually having to pay the tax.

Because we made contact then and because they know that I think that tax is a fucking joke and that I think the same of any outfit which administers it, those people who must pay the tax have been in touch ever since. They send me the letters they get from their housing associations and councils and ring and email when they get a call or a visit from the above and then I ring the relevant housing associations and/or councils and say, basically, “so are you going to evict people who can’t pay the tax, because I’m talking to people who can’t pay the tax and they want to know if they are going to be evicted as anyone would because nobody wants to be evicted, don’t you think.”

That is exactly what happened last week. Some tenants in south Liverpool who I have come to know made contact to say that there’d been housing officers in their street in the company of a uniformed individual who they thought was a copper (South Liverpool Housing was at pains to point out to me later that the person in the uniform was a community support officer and not a copper, but I have to say I didn’t really care. The point was that people saw the uniform and felt a fear).

Anyway, the housing officers and the uniformed person dropped letters through the doors of people who weren’t home.

The letter said  “We note from our records that you have failed to make any payments towards the bedroom tax. It is important that you contact us immediately to make payment arrangements. We have tried to visit you today to discuss this with you in more detail and to provide you with some options to consider. Please contact us to discuss the impact of the bedroom tax on your household or to arrange a suitable appointment.”

So I rang the HA and sent a bunch of questions (six) about this letter and this door-to-door visiting thing they’re doing with people who “must” pay this shit tax and the HA came back and said that I could speak to someone on Tuesday morning about it (Monday was a bank holiday). I thought about that and decided that I didn’t feel like waiting that long and that I’d be posting the story about the letter before Tuesday, so I went back and told them that and I said something like “how about you answer a couple of the questions before Tuesday as I’ll be posting before then.” I said that because I did not and do not feel that there is all the time in the world to spare on these issues and also being told to wait just generally makes me feel like I don’t want to wait. They agreed. So they came back and told me that the door-to-door visits were part of a regular community event called Walkabout Wednesdays – this is where HA people head out into the community and talk to tenants.

And so I put this in the article:

“SLH was at pains to explain that last week’s home visits were nothing unusual – that the Pay Your Bedroom Tax Now letter-drop merely coincided with a regular community meet-and-greet exercise that SLH calls…. “Walkabout Wednesdays.” That’s one interpretation of last week’s event. Another interpretation – it’s certainly one that went through the minds of our tenant contacts (and our minds, for that matter) –  is that tenants are being doorstepped for this bedroom tax money, a mere month after the tax was introduced. A demand for money is a demand for money, whether or not it is delivered on Walkabout Wednesday. People are very concerned that they will lose their housing over this tax. They’re certainly not confident that they’ll keep their homes.”

Which brings us to my phone ringing last Tuesday morning at 10am and me finding this senior SLH person on the other end of it. I was sitting there on my bed smelling like dog and thinking – I wonder if this guy knows that I’m sitting on my bed smelling like dog. Maybe not.

He seemed a genuine and reasonable guy, but this is the problem in this day and age and this is the point that I must make as clear as I can – ALL of these people seem so genuine and reasonable and even appealing. They seem genuine and reasonable and appealing to an extent that no person has ever been in real life in the history of our species.

This is an age – a long one, mind, as this has been going on for as long as I can remember – where smooth talkers and professional calmer-downers and de-fusers are detailed off to “handle” bloggers (not mainstream journalists – they’ve already been de-fused and handled to the point where they no longer need to be de-fused and handled) and to make vile and unreasonable policies like the bedroom tax and the collection of it sound not only eminently reasonable, but like an okay day out.

And so it was with this guy. He talked for ages about Walkabout Wednesdays and how these meet-and-greet events were held regularly to keep in touch with vulnerable (I hate that word) tenants and make sure they were all right and so that people could raise any issues and talk directly to their housing association so on and so forth… and then he also said that last week’s Walkabout Wednesday simply presented another very good chance for the housing association to catch up with anyone who was affected by the bedroom tax and to remind them that if they hadn’t paid it, they should come in and talk about ways to do that and that he wanted to make the point again that the housing association didn’t agree with the tax, but since it had to be collected, they wanted to talk to people about the best ways to go about that and how to help people budget and so on and so on and…Jesus wept. I’m telling you. These people can fucking speak. Time just wafted on and on with this pleasant, intelligent, reasonable and appealing (We Don’t Like It Either – type statement) male voice on the end of the phone pouring oil and pouring oil and I could feel myself being Borged. I had to force myself to snap out of it. Then he had a go, gently, at the paragraph (the one I copied above) I had written. Here is is again:

“SLH was at pains to explain that last week’s home visits were nothing unusual – that the Pay Your Bedroom Tax Now letter-drop merely coincided with a regular community meet-and-greet exercise that SLH calls…. “Walkabout Wednesdays.” That’s one interpretation of last week’s event. Another interpretation – it’s certainly one that went through the minds of our tenant contacts (and our minds, for that matter) –  is that tenants are being doorstepped for this bedroom tax money, a mere month after the tax was introduced. A demand for money is a demand for money, whether or not it is delivered on Walkabout Wednesday. People are very concerned that they will lose their housing over this tax. They’re certainly not confident that they’ll keep their homes.”

That’s just a fact. A demand for money is a demand for money, no matter how sweetly that demand is presented. I would actually say that the fact that some people seriously believe that it is possible to present a demand for money/a threat to housing in an endearing way is off the planet. But still –

This guy thought me calling this Walkabout Wednesday a “Pay Your Bedroom Tax Now” letter-drop was a little bit unfair, or something like that. I was just sitting there on the bed and I thought – Unfair? FUCK UNFAIR, brother. I am so fucking sick of this. Unfair is being tapped for £14 a week when you’re on a benefit so that a cunt like George Osborne can splash our money out on a meadow for himself. It’s as simple as that. It really is as simple as that. There is no grey area here.

And so I told this bloke that there was nothing unfair about my interpretation and that people who were being chased for money for this tax were perfectly entitled to take a view of that pursuit. If people look out of their windows and see several housing association officers and a person who looks like a copper and then they come downstairs to find a letter which says they owe money and must contact their landlord immediately to arrange to pay it – then they’re perfectly entitled to feel that they’re being doorstepped for money they haven’t got. They’re perfectly entitled to feel threatened. Hardly matters if the person who delivers the letter has the human touch and is a scream at parties or offers to “help” if you come into the office to talk about finding the extra money for the bedroom tax by making cutbacks to your gas and heating bill and other necessities. There’s no way to sugarcoat what is happening here. I rent privately and if my landlord said he was putting up the rent and then turned up with an officer a month later to ask where it was, I’d think – FUCK. I wouldn’t be thinking – hey, Walkabout Wednesday. Ace. Walkabout over here, comrades. Give me a letter telling me I’m fucked. And please – come again. I appreciate your visits. And sure – a lot of housing officers will be having a shitty time enforcing this. I know that. Some of my best friends are housing officers. I really mean that as well – some of my best friends ARE housing officers. I used to work in council and was active in the union and there were a lot of housing stewards who I knew across the boroughs who were and still are great friends. They hate all of this. But they don’t try to tell me that they’re doing their best with it, or that they’re trying to make it as painless as they can. They tell me it’s shit, that they feel their job now is basically to make people homeless and that we’re doomed.

So that was that call. That’s the sort of thing those people say. They are masters at massaging the shit out of situations which are made only of shit. It’s a skill and it’s a skill that people pay for.

But then my phone rang again. It was Sean, a man from Northamptonshire who I’m regularly in contact with. He has Asperger’s syndrome and his wife, Maggie, has schizophrenia. I went to his Atos assessment last year. They literally get a smack in the face from government every week now (I’ve seen their paperwork – it’s quite something). In the last month, Sean and Maggie have had bedroom tax demands (they have one “spare” room), a council tax demand (their tax used to be covered by council tax benefit) and then on Tuesday, Maggie got a letter from the jobcentre saying that she would be moved from incapacity benefit to employment and support allowance, which means that she will probably be called to an Atos assessment at some point. She was, naturally, terrified. She was so frightened that she couldn’t talk to me about it. I ended up speaking with Sean instead.

The thing is – and this is the part that I’m going round and round on – I don’t know what to do. I’m very happy to talk to people and to publicise their problems if they want that, but I’m not a welfare expert, or an advisor and so I’m not helping people very much, or very well. I can direct people to the CAB, or their local welfare rights advisors, if there are still any around, but after that, I don’t know what to do. If councillors aren’t interested and “welfare reform” is the only political game in town and government restrospectively changes legislation to beat decisions which may just have given a few people a bit of breathing space, what are people supposed to do?

And the thing is – often, now, people are worried about making themselves and/or their issues known to people who are perceived to be in any sort of position of authority, or part of the “machine.” Housing associations tell me that they’re trying to “help” people budget and to tell people to contact them if they’re having problems with rent and other costs – but when people who are having those problems hear that, they just snort. And who can blame them? These are the same associations that are sending them payment demands.

What a fucking mess. Seriously. And that’s just a couple of hours out of one day. Most of my days as a journalist are like this now. I honestly don’t know what to do with this information.

24 thoughts on “The bedroom tax, austerity and death by the political class

  1. Excellent post Kate articulating much I have been feeling. I worry about members of my family who require social security and now this is replicated throughout the country with safety net after safety net being taken away. It is cruel and dehumanising. And yes I have no idea what to do either. One thing you have to do is continue to publise it – keep telling these people’s stories because you are about the only one I know who is.

  2. Hi I’ve just read some at times you have made me laugh so ta for that being a disabled person I could bang on to you but for sure you are right who writes the fekin script for the prats my own personnel fight I’ve done alone my story is horrific I believe I’m not the norm just for the fact I functioned for 49 years on a congenital heart block leaving me as I am but hey I’m here fought for my own income still fighting for a home last week saw some nasty now controlling my air so this week medic giving top up of meds I’m taking a break as physically and mentally I’m on meltdown and unless I sort I can’t really on any other and for one I’m sick to the back teeth of the lot of em

  3. Nice one Kate I look forward to the nationals printing my story it’s true provable not based on scandal media my very long fight which I’m winning is true and fact at just what some of us do endure so thanks for writing this

  4. I can feel you’re at bursting point from your words and I can understand your frustration and helplessness because I feel the same. Since getting on Twitter a few months ago I’ve spent my days reading and reading and replying to people about bedroom tax, workfare, atos, royal mail & nhs & legal aid privatisations / sell-offs.
    I’m at the end of my tether. I don’t know what to do. We’re ok (for now) in that we’re not directly on the receiving end of all this shit, but I can see it and feel it seaping into our lives every day…..You’re right, it’s a fucking powder-keg situation. It’s also a put-up & shut-up, be thankful for what you’ve got, divisve media-fuelled sitution…..we do what we can but it’s never enough as we’d like. Keep posting these stories. Keep calm in the face of ‘reasonable neo-marxist bullshit’. We’re all of us in this together…..one pay-cheque away from destitution. xx

  5. Kate, I understand your frustration. I am afraid I haven’t got any immediate solutions. I have posted your article on our local list. But what meadow are you referring to? This isn’t about homelessness is it, not really, if that is what you mean. It’s about the ethos of this government of taxing the poor instead of the rich r and getting rid of the social security system. Labour as well of course will be no help.

    I am in the Greens who are the only party on the left of spectrum now. The Brighton Greens have recently brought in an anti-eviction notice in Brighton and we intend to approach our own Council on that one, though our Council is Tory lead so not sure how successful that will be.

    What I wanted to say though is that it shouldn’t be about social issues v environmental issues. Preserving a meadow may be for very good reason. There are, obviously, long term ways of addressing problems such as this, an unconditional citizen’s income, land value tax, ideas the Greens have. The Greens are also ultimately anti-cuts, despite the Brighton stuff.

    Carrie @citizenerased22 on twitter

  6. I find it so fekin funny that in 2008 I awoke no use of legs 49years heartbeat at 40 you see I was born with a congenital heartblock untreated leaving me as I am today ok 29years paid in ni shortfall meant no money dla I did at tribunal alone got high mobility high care no home council put me in a flat totally unsuitable partner 25years no bed for him mounting debts meant we had to live apart 3years on same 2011 ot reported housing needs boy have I shouted council lied to lgo equality screaming courts job loses in council finally a person came into council 7weeks on top of housing list could write vvvvlong account of this what I’m trying to say is no one to help just me shouting telling them what I think all support me medic police blah blah but all I can say most of em thick clueless arseholes I be very glad to get this whole lot in print as I’m told it will be so for sure if this system dragging you down to the lowest of the low fight em tell em like it is cos for sure no one ain’t gonna do it for you plenty of clucking plenty of labels put on you anything but answer you and if they do its lies to cover there scrawny arses

  7. Well, well. No support from the Labour party for disabled people facing eviction due to a vindictive housing benefit ‘reform’.

    That would be the Labour Party, who brought in ATOS to attack disabled peoples’ entitlement to benefits, who still support this as a core policy, and who are joining in the mass-media bandwagon of attacks on the disabled in particular and benefit recipients in general.

    That would be the Labour Party, who can take a core of ‘working class’ voters for granted in all constituencies, and who are chasing middle-class voters in the suburbs. Feel free to take this up with your MP but do check beforehand: some Labour MPs take money from ATOS… And Serco, and Group4: companies who will profit from placing disabled people in residential care.

    Do, please, check whether your Labour MP represents anyone who doesn’t pay them, or pay the minister they aspire to be.

    Of course, your Labour MP, your Labour Councillor, and your local party worthies might be perfectly honest, and just ever-so-embarrassed about ‘social issues’ that make for awkward pauses in the dinner-party conversation, and are best kept quiet because That Kind of Thing is bad for house prices. It’s a middle-class thing, we prefer not to talk about it.

    Go on: see how many times you hear ‘Housing’, instead of ‘House Prices’. Your political representatives are not of a class that represents *you*.

    And the people at the sharp end of it, facing chouces over foid, fuel bills, and eviction? They just got a lesson in the political sytem that superseeded representative democracy.

    Watch what happens when civil disobedience and rent strikes start to happen: that’s ‘extremism’, the kind of politics that has ‘ringleaders’. You can get arrested for that.

    • Thank you so much for saying this. I know a lot of people are aware of Labour’s right-wing policies, but many aren’t – with the result that we basically live in a one-party State, as they carry on voting for Labour under the misaprehension that they oppose tory policies. It annoys me beyond belief to see, during elections, Labour posters in windows in this, a predominantly working-class town. Labour is THE problem of British politics. The problem in a sense is not the Tories. We always know we will get shit from a Tory. But many Labour voters are living in some strange fantasy world, where they imagine Labour policies are as they were in the 1970s. The result is that the Tories have in effect no opposition, nothing ever changes for the better, awful policies are implemented with no opposition, and vast numbers of the population are without representation. My belief is that Labour are liars, charlatans and shysters. I simply can’t understand the lack of logic of people, believing the anti-tory rhetoric from Labour (i.e. slagging off the benefit ‘reforms’), but unwilling to face up to the fact that Labour’s core policies are tory, and they have no intention of reversing any of these tory policies. Yvette Cooper on the TV today didn’t, wouldn’t, couldn’t answer one straight question put to her about anything.

  8. Have to sayi don’t believe anybody 3 years I’ve been shut down no home for my needs I’ve been poked shouted at my bathroom ceiling is split I’ve endured 3years of who lives above me bangs on ceiling at my walk in shower which ot states noisy by nature I am just trusting those who say they are going to get me out of here but no leave the politics out I’ve dealt with both cant really see any difference to be honest for sure not any political party could argue about my health something to do with being degenerative and no cure

  9. Kate , thanks for being you thanks for saying it as it is, like you I do not know which way to turn.

    The sick the disabled the poor the unemployed are being trampled on in such a destructive and uncompromising way by this coalition , but they are getting no help or support from Labour in fact the silence of Milliband and co on these issues apart from a bit of grandstanding at the odd rally or march is deafening silence .

    I feel your frustration your anger and your pain along with your sense of utter despair and helplessness, but these folk need you they need somebody to talk to that cares. The fact you are prepared to be an outlet for the fears of so many when most journalists no longer give a shit, at least offers these folk a brief respite from the war of hate hat is being raged against them. For the very first time in my seventy years on this planet I joined a political party and I chose Labour because I knew my 49year od daughter who has Downs Syndrome would need to be protected from the evil dehumanising of disabled people Cameron and Clegg have engaged in from day one, so aptly summed up recently by a wheelchair bound elderly lady when she said ” I can’t understand what’s happened a few months ago I was a poor dear, and now I’m a scrounging skiving bastard”. I genuinely thought that Labour would fight to defend our Susan and her peers but as you rightly point out they are all but condoning the actions of hatred being visited on all the groups you mention. Needless to say I will not be renewing my one year relationship with Labour, to do so would be to dance with the devil that is supporting the destruction of disability support services and quality of life for the sick and the disabled.

    Kate be down be angry be vexed be stressed be hurt but be there, because these folk need you more than you could ever understand

  10. Pingback: The bedroom tax, austerity and death by the political class

  11. I think the issue you raise about the ‘reasonableness’ of so many people in positions of power, is spot on.
    I thought of this post when watching BBC Newsnight last night – where the head of Oxford City County responded to the question that a girl’s mother had tried to report allegations of abuse to the council and found literally no help at all, by saying that the council “hadn’t listened enough, hadn’t done enough…” and that she won’t resign as she wants to “raise awareness of the issue of abuse” in future. At no point did she seem to understand the gravity of it, or certainly didn’t show any emotion or passion. Or indeed admit that rather than not having done enough, had not in fact done anything at all to prevent such abuse.
    Her three or four minute interview starts at about 17mins15secs:
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01sjjw3/Newsnight_14_05_2013/

  12. As a disabled person apart from my medics I can state hand on heart nobody listens you are permanently on a roller coaster pushed from pillar to post I’ve been poked shouted at my whole story is very lengthy for what I’ve endured I’m surprised I’m still here for sure you get a label it is an absolute farce nobody listens I’ve had 3years of pure hell even down to another tenant determining how much air I have I’m grateful to my medics family and friends who have supported me in my right for an income and a home abusers come in many guises

  13. Pingback: The bedroom tax, austerity and smackdown by the political class | Kate Belgrave

Leave a Reply to Brigitte Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.